Down Under: Cause and Means.


This is a little maddening.

A group of 10 protestors gathered outside the facilities at the ASB Classic in Auckland New Zealand to protest the participation of Israeli player Shahar Peer. The protest noise from outside the tennis complex at one point stopped the play with Peer looking visibly unhappy. The protestors chanted through a loudspeaker, “blood, blood on your hands”, “freedom for Palestine”, and “go home, Shahar” accompanied by drums.

A 15 minute argument ensued, with the tournament officials wanting to stop the match and deal with the noise, while Peer and her coach insisted they play on. As play resumed, Peer channeled her inner rage and blitzed through the rest of the match, steamrolling Rybarikova 6-1 6-0.

 

 

Sport and politics always make for an interesting, if not controversial issue. The instinct here is to jump all over the protestors, and for the most part, I’ve got to agree. But in the interest of fairness, hear what they have to say about their actions. 

 

The group sent Peer, 22, a letter asking her to withdraw “as a demonstration of your commitment to peace” and plan to protest until she does, or is knocked out of the tournament.

Protester Janfrie Wakim, of the Palestine Human Rights Campaign Auckland, said sport was an important part of the boycott campaign.

“That is an argument that is used in the past, but it is one of the ways to get some leverage, and we saw that in South Africa and we saw it so effectively in rugby. Of course the argument is politics and sport don’t mix, well, politics affects the lives of every Palestinian – they have no chance of being involved in sport and this is an opportunity for us to affect those policies.

[Peer] has declared her service to the Israeli Army, and she is apparently a very good shot. She hasn’t joined a lot of other young Israelis and become a refusenik, which she could have easily done if she had the courage to do so.”

 

I’ve got to say – I’m sympathetic to their cause. In fact, I’m probably one of the few out there who are willing to give politics a place in sports.

To put it simply, politics is people. And so is sport.

Given the amount of money, fame and media attention in professional sports, why not use it as a platform to speak out and affect social change? After all, we weren’t wagging our fingers when North and South Korea marched out as one team at the Sydney Olympics opening ceremony. Was that not a positive political statement of unity and peace?

The problem here isn’t the cause of their political activism, or the fact that they tried to politicize sport. What is problematic is the means through which  they’re trying to achieve their end

Essentially, what the group is trying to do here is to bully a girl into giving up her livelihood because they don’t agree with her country’s politics. 

Has anyone ever protested the presence of American players in tournaments because of the existence of Guantanamo Bay? Or requested Chinese players to withdraw for failing to speak out against their government’s human rights record? 

I have a problem with Lindt’s supply chain, which often involves forced labour and child slavery on cocoa plantations. Does that mean I should ask Roger to give up his sponsorship deal? 

If not, then why is it okay to force an Israeli player to give up her profession because of politics

By all means, be politically active. Campaign for your cause. But choose the means through which you protest carefully. Because something like this could backfire on your cause in the media and turn popular support against you.

Color me surprised if most people out there don’t look on the protesters’ actions with a little disgust.

Tags:

4 responses to “Down Under: Cause and Means.”

  1. braggaditis says :

    [The problem here isn’t the cause of their political activism, or the fact that they tried to politicize sport. What is problematic is the means through which they’re trying to achieve their end. ]

    ahhh. Brilliantly written.
    Completely agreed. I can understand their disappointment. But this becomes a campaign for a *noise* instead of a campaign for a cause, when done against a helpless player whose only fault is going over there to play tennis.

  2. Rowan says :

    Hey Dootsiez! Great post. I like your blog a lot.

    I’m from Auckland and was at the Peer Rybarikova match today. It was really noisy. The same group protested Peer’s presence at the tournament last year, but this was the first day they brought their drum kit along.

    You’re right about the protestors turning people off. Every person in that tennis centre was as mad as a wet hen. Nobody was going to be joining their facebook page any time soon.

    As a tennis fan I sometimes feel like walking up to the protestors and explaining to them how tennis is different from other sports. Shahar Peer organises her own schedule and pays for her own plane tickets (I think). She may have the letters ISR next to her name in the draw, but she’s not a national team, if you know what I mean. She’s announced from Israel, but she’s not playing for Israel. She’s playing for herself.

    But I’m sure the protestors have heard this all before and still stand by their argument. I wish they’d keep it down though. Tennis likes it quiet.

    • dootsiez says :

      Hi Rowan, thanks for the report.

      I wish they kept it quiet too. If they *have* to target Peer, just send her a letter. Don’t then stalk her, and ruin the spectator’s fun and both players’ moods.

      Something tells me this is more about attention-seeking than any real drive for political change.

      • Blue says :

        I pretty much agree with everything you wrote. I’m glad the incident didn’t affect her ability to win. It must have been for attention, did they really expect the letter to stop her from playing in a tournament she qualified and prepared for?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: